THIBAUD PAVLOVIC-HOBBA violin
WILMA SMITH violin
HELEN IRELAND viola
ZOE KNIGHTON cello
AGATHA YIM, POLYPHONIC PICTURES filming and editing
THOMAS GRUBB, MANO MUSICA sound engineering, editing and mastering
Filmed August 2022 at Tempo Rubato, Brunswick
This project was made possible through support from the Victorian Government through Creative Victoria and Australia Council
HAYDN & BRAHMS
JOSEPH HAYDN 1732-1809
String Quartet in A major, Op. 20, No. 6 (composed 1772)
I. Allegro di molto e scherzando
II. Adagio
III. Minuet - Trio
IV. Fuga con tre soggetti
“Every page of the six quartets of Op. 20 is of historic and aesthetic importance… there is perhaps no single or sextuple opus in the history of instrumental music which has achieved so much or achieved it so quietly…” - Sir Donald Francis Tovey
Haydn’s Op. 20 was his third set of quartets written at the house of the Esterházy family so having 12 quartets under his belt, he took one mighty leap forward and ensured the string quartet had a permanent place, laying the first major stepping stones for this magic combination of four instruments. No wonder Beethoven wrote the six Op. 20 quartets out in full to have his own copy and as a form of study (in much the same way an artist may copy a masterpiece).
Do we thank Count Esterházy? Do we thank the musicians of the time? Perhaps Haydn’s mum and dad for his talents as a composer and musician? Every string quartet written since (and this is no exaggeration) can be traced back to Haydn’s string quartets numbers 13-18, his Opus 20.
Named the “Sun” Quartets after an image that appeared on the first edition, they are also sunny in nature with the first movement being inherently playful (as the term scherzando would suggest) and Haydn’s practical joke of choice - silence - coming into play between the development and recapitulation. He also commands at times that the first violin is to play solely on one string, which can either be comical or virtuosic depending on the musical context. We have often wondered what the first violin at the Esterházy house did to incur such an inconvenient marking.
The second movement is akin to an Aria or song which is not surprising as Haydn was composing a great deal of opera for the Esterházy house at the same time. In the third movement, which has hints of the first movement in its themes, the term trio is taken quite literally and Haydn not only omits the second violin entirely (perhaps to enable them to take an extra sip of wine) but demands all three remaining players to play solely on one string. It seems the entire joke was on the musicians.
The final movement is a masterpiece in fugal writing. With three parts (tre soggeti) and to be played sempre sotto voce it has all the tricks of the trade that Beethoven would later use in his grand Grosse Fugue Op. 133. Haydn even marks the section that is an upside-down version of the theme for the players, just so we can appreciate how clever he is.
“He could amuse, shock, arouse laughter and deep emotion as no other.” - Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart speaking about Franz Joseph Haydn
JOHANNES BRAHMS 1833-1897
String Quartet No. 1 in C minor, Op. 51, No. 1 (completed 1873)
I. Allegro
II. Romanze. Poco adagio
III. Allegretto molto moderato e comodo - Un poco più animato
IV. Allegro
It’s no secret that Brahms lived constantly in Beethoven’s shadow and he famously said of his first symphony when someone commented on the similarity to the “Ode to Joy” theme, “Any Ass can see that.”
(At the University of Melbourne in the 1990s, a first-year music history assignment was: “Brahms’ first symphony is Beethoven’s 10th - discuss”)
Brahms was notoriously self-critical, destroying early manuscripts and some accounts list as many as 20 quartets that never saw the light of day before this one. The reverence to his predecessors was palpable with Brahms writing to his publisher that, just as Mozart had taken extreme care over the quartets dedicated to Haydn, Brahms intended to be just as mindful. Here above all Brahms found that “It is not hard to compose, but what is fabulously hard is to leave the superfluous notes under the table.” Chamber music had played a crucial part in his composition around this time - the early version of the B major trio, the original version of the piano quintet for string quintet (two cellos) and the horn trio to name a few, but it was the relatively sparse and revealing string quartet that raised his anxieties about his own artistic capability.
"You have no idea of how it feels - always to hear the tramp of such a giant [Beethoven] behind you." - Johannes Brahms
This first quartet is in C minor - no accident that he chose the same key as the mighty 5th symphony of Beethoven which also is the key of Brahms’ first symphony. Brahms unifies the movements with a connection in the thematic material with dotted rhythms, minor scalic motion, melodies with falling sevenths; they all combine to ensure the movements fit together like a perfect jigsaw. His characteristic duplet against triplet rhythmical treatment is a feature throughout the quartet. The whole piece reads like a unified story with motivic development throughout each movement much the same way a great novel develops characters throughout each chapter.
Players tend to believe that the quartet they are playing in any particular moment is their favourite but there is something about the sound world created by Brahms, how gratifying each individual part is to play and how the parts interlocks that make this work one of the greatest romantic quartets of all time. It seems Brahms took almost eight years of creative thinking and gestation to get this piece onto the concert stage. We say it was worth the wait.